Multimagic squares records
|
Power |
Square & Order |
Inventor |
Country |
Date |
|
1 |
Hetu Luosu |
China |
2800 before J-C |
|
|
2 |
Chen Qinwu, Chen Mutian |
China |
June 2005 |
|
|
G. Pfeffermann |
France |
1890 |
||
|
3 |
Gaston Tarry |
France |
1905 |
|
|
General Eutrope Cazalas |
France |
1933 |
||
|
William H. Benson |
USA |
1976 (*) |
||
|
Chen Qinwu, Chen Mutian |
China |
2005 |
||
|
Chen Qinwu, Chen Mutian |
China |
May 2005 |
||
|
Walter Trump |
Germany |
2002 |
||
|
4 |
Christian Boyer - André Viricel |
France |
2001 |
|
|
Christian Boyer |
France |
January 2003(**) |
||
|
Pan Fengchu |
China |
February 2004 |
||
|
5 |
Christian Boyer - André Viricel |
France |
2001 |
|
|
Li Wen |
China |
June 2003 |
||
|
6 |
Pan Fengchu |
China |
December 2003 |
(*)
In his book published in 1976, William Benson points out that he built this
32nd-order trimagic square as far back as 1949.
(**) Another
tetramagic square of order 256 was constructed
nearly simulteanously by two Chinese, Wu
Shuoxin et
Gao Zhiyuan. Information
announced February 24th 2003 by Gao
Zhiyuan. See
his site.
Magic square is a typical difficult NPC problem, its calculation complexity increases sharply when order n increasing, there are some questions that can not be solved completely even the order smaller than 10.
The table above only lists the same order multimagic square which is first discovered.
To construct a multimagic square, we can use the methods as follows:
1. Arranging the multimagic squares ingeniously by the methods of combinatorics.
2. Using the searching algorithm to find the multimagic squares by computer.
The order of the multimagic squares produced by the former method is big, like trimagic squares or above, their orders are all above 32. The latter is affected by the speed of the computer greatly:The order increases 1 every time, then the difficulty would increase thousand times. It is extremely difficult to find a 13th or higher multimagic square at present.
Therefore, all the 12th to 31st multimagic squares are difficult problems. In this region, there are only the 12th trimagic square discovered by Walter Trump (German), and the 16th and the 24th discovered by Chen Qinwu, Chen Mutian (Shantou University, China).
If you have the following inventive multimagic square which hasn’t been published, welcome to mail this Magic square website for publication:
1) 13th to 31st trimagic squares
2) 13th to 31st bimagic squares, but the same order trimagic squares of which doesn’t exist or hasn’t been published.
3) Magic squares with 4 or higher power, but smaller order than the “Multimagic square records” above.